| Player | Year | Set | Grade | Number | ||
| Johan Santana | 2000 | Fleer Tradition Update | PSA 9 | U43 | ||
| Rocco Baldelli | 2000 | High School All Americans | PSA 9 | 3 | ||
| Albert Pujols | 2000 | Multi-Ad Midwest League Top Prospect | PSA 9 | 20 | ||
| Albert Pujols | 2000 | Multi-Ad Midwest League Top Prospect | PSA 9 | 20 | ||
| Albert Pujols | 2000 | Multi-Ad Midwest League Top Prospect | PSA 9 | 20 | ||
| Trot Nixon | 2001 | Topps | PSA 8 | 561 | ||
| Ichiro Suzuki | 2001 | Topps Chrome Traded | PSA 9 | T266 | ||
| Joe Mauer | 2002 | Just Prospects Prototype | PSA 9 | JPP10 | ||
| Joe Mauer | 2002 | Topps 206 Piedmont Black | PSA 9 | 271 | ||
| Jon Papelbon | 2003 | Bowman Chrome Draft Picks | PSA 9 | BDP51 | ||
| Clay Buchholz | 2003 | Bowman Chrome Draft Picks | PSA 9 | BDP81 | ||
| Felix Hernandez | 2004 | Bowman Draft Picks | PSA 9 | 150 | ||
| Wade Boggs | 2005 | SP Legendary Cuts | PSA 10 | 84 | ||
| Jacoby Ellsbury | 2005 | Topps Chrome U&H | PSA 9 | UH202 | ||
| David Price | 2005 | 2005 Upper Deck USA National Team | PSA 9 | USA59 | ||
| Justin Verlander | 2006 | Allen & Ginter | PSA 9 | 74 | ||
| Justin Verlander | 2006 | Topps '52 | PSA 9 | 310 | ||
| Jason Heyward | 2007 | Bowman Chrome | PSA 10 | BDPP54 | ||
| David Price | 2007 | Bowman Chrome | PSA 10 | BDPP55 | ||
| Clayton Kershaw | 2007 | Bowman Chrome | PSA 9 | BDPP77 | ||
| Evan Longoria | 2007 | Bowman Chrome | PSA 9 | BDPP99 | ||
| Clayton Kershaw | 2008 | Topps Allen & Ginter | PSA 9 | 72 |